11+ players · Setup

A Death Off the Books

The Bishop taxes the Assassins’ knife. The Terrorist’s exit does not go through the parish.

Playing with plain cards or index paper? Upgrade your table with The Final Witness Mafia Card Deck—featuring 28 custom illustrated cards, balanced setups, host scripts, and a zero-elimination mechanic that keeps every player alive and active until the end.

11+players + host
4night wakes
3Mafia cards
Two ledgersnot every death is equal

How this deal plays

Two Assassins do the regular killing, and the Priest taxes them for it: if they kill him, their next night is cancelled. But the Mafia carries a way around the parish — the Terrorist, who once per game points at a player and takes them down with him. That kill is not an assassin kill, so the Priest's protection means nothing against it. The City has a Doctor and a true-speaking Policeman; what it does not have is certainty about which deaths went through which ledger.

The deal: who gets which cards

Shuffle exactly these cards for 11 or more living players, plus one host, and deal one face down to each person. Look at your card once, hide it, and say whatever you like for the rest of the game — the card is the only proof of anything.

Night order for this setup

The host calls these wakes in this order, every night, reading from a written list. Skip nothing, rush nothing — the spoken lines are on the mafia game narrator script.

  1. 01

    Assassins

    They wake together, agree on one victim in silence, and point.

  2. 02

    Terrorist

    Once per game, may pick a player. Both die. He may also sleep without pointing.

  3. 03

    Doctor

    Heals one player. Not herself two nights in a row.

  4. 04

    Policeman

    Checks one player's team each night. The answer is always true.

Tips for this deal

If you are City

A two-body dawn means the Terrorist has moved — and one of those bodies is his. Read that morning carefully; it is the loudest clue this deal produces. And if you are the Priest, do not advertise: your card only punishes the knife, not the vote.

If you are Mafia

Spend the Terrorist like the last banknote he is. Trading one-for-one with a Citizen loses the game; trading for the Doctor, the cop, or the Priest can win it.

If you are hosting

Track the Priest exactly: only an assassin kill on him cancels their next night. A day vote does nothing. The Terrorist does nothing. When the cancel fires, run the Assassins' wake as a dummy so the table cannot hear the hole.

The Priest's exact rule, and why a vote never triggers it, is on his card page and in the mafia game rules.

Mafia card game

Buy the Mafia Game Cards Now

One box, up to 27 players, and a room that won't stop talking about it tomorrow. The Final Witness delivers the complete 1900 East London experience—featuring 48 premium 310gsm cards, a built-in Narrator script, and the Final Witness Vote to eliminate player downtime forever.

  • 48 Cards Total — Complete deck on premium 310gsm casino stock
  • 28 Character Cards — 27 playable London figures plus 1 Narrator
  • 20 Final Witness Cards — Physical markers to track dead players
  • Zero Player Elimination — Dead players stay active to vote until the end
  • Digital QR Access — Instant rules, setups, and lore on every card back
$34.95 −22% $45.00
Orders start shipping in January 2027

Secure checkout · shipping on the payment page · duties and customs paid